Justia Maryland Supreme Court Opinion Summaries

Articles Posted in Family Law
by
A mother surrendered her four-day-old twin sons at a hospital under Maryland’s Safe Haven Act, which allows parents to leave unharmed newborns at designated facilities within sixty days of birth, granting immunity from criminal prosecution and civil liability for the act of surrender. The mother left the twins with identifying information but did not disclose her identity, provide information about alternative caregivers, or express intent to return. Hospital staff found the twins healthy and notified the local department of social services, which took custody and placed them in foster care. The department later identified both parents through family contact and DNA testing. Mother participated in proceedings and argued that her actions did not constitute neglect under the Child in Need of Assistance (CINA) statute, and that Safe Haven Act immunity precluded such a finding.The Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County, sitting as the juvenile court, held a de novo hearing and found that the mother’s actions amounted to neglect, as the twins were left without a legal custodian or provision for long-term care, placing them at substantial risk of harm. The court denied mother’s request to award custody to the father and committed the twins to the department’s care. Both parents appealed. The Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the neglect finding, concluding that abandonment under the Safe Haven Act can constitute neglect if court intervention is required to prevent harm, and that Safe Haven immunity from “civil liability” does not shield against a CINA neglect determination.The Supreme Court of Maryland reviewed the case and affirmed the Appellate Court’s judgment. The court held that a parent who surrenders a newborn under the Safe Haven Act may be found to have neglected the child within the meaning of the CINA statute if the child is left without a legal custodian or provision for care, placing the child at substantial risk of harm. The court further held that Safe Haven Act immunity from “civil liability” does not preclude a CINA neglect finding. View "In re: B.Cd. & B.Cb." on Justia Law

by
A father filed a petition in the District Court of Maryland, sitting in Montgomery County, seeking protection on behalf of his 11-year-old child from the child’s mother. The petition alleged repeated physical abuse, including punching and hitting with objects. Based on the allegations, the District Court entered an interim protective order, then a temporary protective order after finding reasonable grounds to believe abuse occurred, and ultimately a final protective order after a hearing. The final order, effective for one year, was supported by findings of a history of abuse.The mother appealed the District Court’s final protective order to the Circuit Court for Montgomery County, requesting and receiving two continuances. During this time, the circuit court issued intervening protective orders that maintained the previous protections and, at the mother’s request, allowed for a supplemental investigation. After a de novo hearing, the circuit court again entered a final protective order, modifying some conditions, and granted the father physical custody of the child. The mother then appealed to the Appellate Court of Maryland. That court transferred the case to the Supreme Court of Maryland, concluding it lacked jurisdiction because the circuit court had exercised appellate, not original, jurisdiction.The Supreme Court of Maryland held that when a circuit court hears a de novo appeal from a District Court’s final protective order under Maryland’s domestic violence statute, the circuit court has authority to issue intervening protective orders pending the final hearing. Issuing such orders does not convert the proceeding into one under the circuit court’s original jurisdiction, and thus, there is no further right of appeal to the Appellate Court of Maryland. The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the Circuit Court for Montgomery County. View "Walston v. Lindsay" on Justia Law

Posted in: Family Law
by
An infant, K.B., was removed from her mother’s care after a police officer witnessed the mother acting abusively toward K.B. and expressing suicidal thoughts. The Baltimore County Department of Social Services filed a petition alleging K.B. was a child in need of assistance (CINA) due to abuse, neglect, and the mother’s history of mental health issues and prior terminations of parental rights. At the adjudication and disposition hearing, the Circuit Court for Baltimore County declared K.B. a CINA, committed her to the Department’s custody, and established supervised visitation. The court’s order included a standard notice that the permanency plan of reunification could later be changed.At a subsequent initial review hearing, the Department recommended changing K.B.’s presumptive plan of reunification to a concurrent plan of reunification and adoption. A magistrate adopted this recommendation, and the juvenile court overruled the mother’s exceptions, ordering the concurrent plan. The mother appealed. The Appellate Court of Maryland reversed, holding that the juvenile court had improperly established a permanency plan before the required permanency plan hearing and without considering the statutory factors or providing proper notice.The Supreme Court of Maryland reviewed whether the juvenile court could change the permanency plan at the initial review hearing. It held that the presumptive plan of reunification established at disposition is not a permanency plan as defined by Maryland law. The court ruled that a permanency plan must be determined at a hearing that complies with statutory requirements, including consideration of specific factors and provision of reasonable notice to all parties about the date, time, and purpose of the hearing. The court affirmed the Appellate Court’s judgment and remanded the case for proper proceedings. View "In re: K.B." on Justia Law

by
A mother filed a petition for protection from child abuse on behalf of her two minor children against their father, following allegations of threats, mental injury, and physical abuse. An ex parte hearing in the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County resulted in a temporary protective order and referral to the Department of Social Services (DSS) for investigation. The DSS report, completed before the final hearing, corroborated the children’s accounts of abusive behavior. At the final hearing, the mother was unrepresented and the father had counsel; after hearing testimony, the court granted a final protective order awarding custody to the mother and supervised visitation to the father.The Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the circuit court’s grant of the final protective order. It found that the circuit court had sufficient basis to extend the temporary protective order pending the DSS investigation, that the father’s right to procedural due process was not violated by not being served with the petition, and that the circuit court’s negative credibility determination of the father’s testimony was enough to support the finding of abuse by a preponderance of the evidence.The Supreme Court of Maryland reviewed three issues. First, it held that the father did not preserve for appellate review the question of whether the circuit court erred by not stating on the record whether good cause existed to set the final hearing beyond seven days of service of the temporary order. Second, the Court held that service of a temporary protective order, which includes factual allegations and notice of the hearing, generally satisfies procedural due process requirements; thus, the father was not entitled to service of the petition in addition. Third, the Court held that the Appellate Court erred by affirming the final protective order solely on the basis of the circuit court’s negative credibility finding; lack of credibility alone does not satisfy the petitioner’s burden of proof. The judgment was affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded for further proceedings. View "Clarke v. Gibson" on Justia Law

Posted in: Family Law
by
After the divorce of two parents, the mother filed a petition in the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County seeking protection from child abuse on behalf of their minor children. She alleged threats of violence and mental injury, but did not check boxes for physical abuse nor provide detailed factual allegations in the petition. At an ex parte hearing, she testified about incidents where the father allegedly struck one child and threatened violence, which led the circuit court to grant a temporary protective order. The court referred the matter to the Department of Social Services for investigation and scheduled the final protective order hearing beyond the statutory seven-day period to accommodate the investigation. At the final hearing, both parties appeared, and the court ultimately granted a final protective order, awarding custody to the mother and imposing supervised visitation and other conditions on the father.On appeal, the Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the circuit court’s grant of the final protective order. It held that the extension of the temporary order for investigative purposes was justified, that the father had received adequate notice of the allegations via the temporary order itself, and that there was sufficient evidence to support the circuit court’s finding of abuse. The appellate court relied primarily on the circuit court’s negative credibility determination of the father’s testimony to uphold the order.The Supreme Court of Maryland reviewed the case. It held that the father did not preserve for appellate review the issue of whether the circuit court erred by not stating on the record whether good cause existed for scheduling the hearing beyond seven days. The court also held that service of a temporary protective order generally satisfies procedural due process requirements; the father’s argument that service of the petition was required was rejected. However, the Supreme Court found the Appellate Court erred in affirming the sufficiency of the evidence solely based on the circuit court’s disbelief of the father’s testimony. That part of the appellate decision was vacated and remanded for further proceedings. View "Clarke v. Gibson" on Justia Law

Posted in: Family Law
by
Erica Hall and Nicholas Houser married in 2012 and have one minor child, C.H., born in 2018. In 2020, both parties sought an absolute divorce. On the trial day, they presented agreements to the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County, including one to waive child support and arrears. The court requested justification for this waiver, but the parties only argued their fitness as parents and their constitutional rights. The court found the waiver in the parents' best interest, not the child's, and ordered Mr. Houser to pay child support and arrears to Ms. Hall, who had primary custody of C.H.The Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the circuit court's decision, rejecting the parents' agreement regarding child support and upholding the child support and arrears order. Both parties then petitioned the Supreme Court of Maryland.The Supreme Court of Maryland held that parents cannot waive the issue of child support because it is a legal obligation, and the right to receive support belongs to the child, not the parents. The court also held that a parent's fundamental right to determine the care, custody, and control of their children does not include waiving child support, as it is a parental obligation. The court found that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in rejecting the parents' agreement to waive child support, as the parties failed to provide sufficient justification for the waiver. The Supreme Court of Maryland affirmed the judgment of the Appellate Court, maintaining the child support and arrears order. View "In re: Marriage of Houser" on Justia Law

Posted in: Family Law
by
In this case, the husband filed for an absolute divorce, and the wife counterclaimed. The parties attempted mediation but did not reach a settlement. The wife’s counsel later sent a settlement package to the husband’s counsel, which included a Voluntary Separation and Property Settlement Agreement, a promissory note, and a guaranty. The cover letter specified that the husband needed to sign the agreement and note by the end of the day on September 25, 2020. The husband signed the documents on September 28, 2020, and filed an amended complaint for divorce based on mutual consent, incorporating the agreement.The Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County found that the husband had timely accepted the wife’s offer and that a binding settlement agreement was formed. The court granted the husband’s motion to enforce the settlement agreement and entered a judgment for absolute divorce based on mutual consent, incorporating but not merging the agreement into the judgment. The wife appealed, and the Appellate Court of Maryland reversed the circuit court’s judgment, finding that the husband had not timely accepted the wife’s offer and that no contract was formed.The Supreme Court of Maryland reviewed the case and affirmed the Appellate Court’s judgment. The court held that the wife’s offer was conditioned on the husband signing the agreement and note by September 25, 2020, and that the husband’s failure to meet this deadline meant that no contract was formed. The court also found no evidence that the wife had waived the deadline. The court concluded that the husband’s signing of the documents on September 28, 2020, constituted a counteroffer, which the wife was not obligated to accept. View "Pattison v. Pattison" on Justia Law

Posted in: Contracts, Family Law
by
A married couple, with three young children, filed for divorce. The mother requested primary custody, pendente lite child support, and alimony, while the father requested primary custody and child support. A family magistrate found both parents capable of earning significant income and denied the mother's request for pendente lite child support and alimony, recommending shared custody and shared payment of the mortgage and utilities for the marital home.The Circuit Court for Howard County adopted the magistrate's recommendations and denied the mother's exceptions to the magistrate's report. The mother appealed, citing Md. Code Ann., Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 12-303(3)(v), which allows appeals from interlocutory orders for the payment of money.The Appellate Court of Maryland dismissed the appeal, holding that an interlocutory order denying pendente lite child support and alimony is not appealable under CJ § 12-303(3)(v) because it does not direct the payment of money. The mother then petitioned the Supreme Court of Maryland for a writ of certiorari.The Supreme Court of Maryland affirmed the Appellate Court's judgment, holding that CJ § 12-303(3)(v) authorizes appeals only from interlocutory orders that direct the payment of money, not from orders denying such requests. The Court concluded that the legislative history and case law support this interpretation, emphasizing that the statute's plain language does not permit appeals from orders denying the payment of money. View "Adelakun v. Adelakun" on Justia Law

by
In this case, Erica Hall and Nicholas Houser, who married in 2012 and have one minor child, sought an absolute divorce in 2020. They presented three agreements to the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County, including one that proposed no child support and waived arrears. The court rejected this agreement, stating it was not in the child's best interest and ordered Mr. Houser to pay child support and arrears to Ms. Hall, who was the primary custodian.The Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the circuit court's decision, rejecting the parents' agreement regarding child support and upholding the award of child support and arrears. Both parties then petitioned the Supreme Court of Maryland for a writ of certiorari.The Supreme Court of Maryland held that parents cannot waive the issue of child support and arrears, even in a bilateral agreement, because child support is a legal obligation, and the right to receive it belongs to the child, not the parents. The court also held that a parent's fundamental right to determine the care, custody, and control of their children does not include the ability to waive child support, as it is a parental obligation, not a right. Therefore, lawfully ordered child support does not violate a parent's fundamental rights.Additionally, the court found that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in rejecting the parents' agreement to pay no child support, as the parties failed to provide sufficient justification for their request. The Supreme Court of Maryland affirmed the judgment of the Appellate Court, maintaining the child support order. View "In re Marriage of Houser" on Justia Law

Posted in: Family Law
by
The case involves a seventeen-year-old named M.Z., who was adjudicated as a child in need of assistance (CINA) by the Circuit Court for Baltimore County due to behavioral issues and her mother's inability to manage her. M.Z. was placed in a therapeutic youth group home and later returned to her mother's custody. The Baltimore County Department of Social Services sought to terminate the CINA case, but M.Z.'s mother objected, citing ongoing behavioral concerns and the need for additional services.The Circuit Court for Baltimore County terminated the CINA case over the mother's objection, finding that the mother could adequately care for M.Z. and that the Department had exhausted its services. The mother appealed to the Appellate Court of Maryland, which dismissed the appeal, holding that the mother was not "aggrieved" by the termination since her custodial rights were restored.The Supreme Court of Maryland reviewed the case to determine whether a parent is entitled to appeal the termination of a CINA case over their objection. The court held that a parent is an "aggrieved party" entitled to appeal if they have not obtained the full relief sought in the juvenile court. The court emphasized that the CINA statute's purpose extends beyond parental rights to include the child's safety and well-being. The court found that the mother's interest in ensuring M.Z.'s safety and receiving necessary services was sufficient to make her an aggrieved party.The Supreme Court of Maryland reversed the judgment of the Appellate Court of Maryland and remanded the case for further proceedings to resolve the merits of the mother's appeal. View "In re M.Z." on Justia Law